There's a soldier in all of us

November 10th, 2011

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 dropped this week to solid reviews, just like Battlefield 3 before it. So which is the better game? Answering that question is largely a matter of taste.

Says one PC gamer after playing: "I guess it all boils down to if you would perfer Battlefield 3. A broken game with numerous bugs that might/might not be fixed soon in patches. Or Modern Warfare 3. A perfectly working game, but with fundamental issues of overly rehashed gameplays that are not technical, but are simply unfixable."

Calling Battlefield 3 "broken" is laying it on a bit thick. And let the record show that Modern Warfare 3's "rehashed gameplay" is still fun.

But the point is: Neither is a "change your life" kind of game, nor as big as their marketing budgets would suggest. Granted, most games aren't. But amid all the hooopla, let's not forget: both of these games are worthwhile shooters best enjoyed with friends.  

Neither is as balanced as the great one (Hi, Counter-Strike). But both are a fresh battlefield for the soldier in all of us. 

For readers who have played both games, what's your initial assesment? 

Read more: PC gaming headlines

Comments

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 
I haven't played either. I'm waiting for CS:GO!

New forums... Soon™

1
Posted Thursday, November 10th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
8026 ARP
6526/2147482148, 2147475622 ARP to go
6526/2147482148, 2147475622 ARP to go
haven't played Battlefield, played MW1,2 and soon, 3. and have always, and WILL ALWAYS play CS. loved CoD and CS alike, hope I get the chance to play BF one of these days. :)) (All hail CS)

I'm not a gamer, i'm just a game fan who plays games.

2
Posted Thursday, November 10th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 2
171 ARP
71/150, 79 ARP to go
71/150, 79 ARP to go
bf3 sucks ea and dice screwed us all... i want my money back so i can get skyrim :D

"To die for the Emperor is better than to live for yourself" -

3
Posted Thursday, November 10th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 2
194 ARP
94/150, 56 ARP to go
94/150, 56 ARP to go
is that the guy from Avatar and Clash of the Titans???

"A single dream is more powerful than a thousand realities." ~ J.R.R. Tolkien

4
Posted Thursday, November 10th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
4956 ARP
3456/2147482148, 2147478692 ARP to go
3456/2147482148, 2147478692 ARP to go
I played some of the campaign its awesome !!

5
Posted Thursday, November 10th, 2011    Quote This Post
iwe
Level 6
1200 ARP
200/500, 300 ARP to go
200/500, 300 ARP to go
Eirreann said: is that the guy from Avatar and Clash of the Titans???
Yes that is Sam Worthington.

6
Posted Thursday, November 10th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
1644 ARP
144/2147482148, 2147482004 ARP to go
144/2147482148, 2147482004 ARP to go
Oh yeah I've seen this before, reminds me of the black ops ad

7
Posted Thursday, November 10th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
1774 ARP
274/2147482148, 2147481874 ARP to go
274/2147482148, 2147481874 ARP to go
Hail CS!
CoD and BF never really got me

8
Posted Thursday, November 10th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 4
506 ARP
6/250, 244 ARP to go
6/250, 244 ARP to go
I'll have MW3 this weekend from my brother, but I'm waiting on my M17x to grab BF3. Everything seems to say the same thing though, it's all down to personal taste.

AWA Game Night admin and derailer of Steam chat room conversations.

9
Posted Thursday, November 10th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
3594 ARP
2094/2147482148, 2147480054 ARP to go
2094/2147482148, 2147480054 ARP to go
I bought the game, and it's awesome. I love the kill confirmed mode, but unfortunately the multiplayer it's laggy for me, soo that sucks.

GOD is a Superstition.

10
Posted Thursday, November 10th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 3
369 ARP
119/250, 131 ARP to go
119/250, 131 ARP to go
I'll try both of them, I think I'll enjoy them despite the fact both have flaws that could had been corrected. (But I don't think either of them will change my life like CS did )

Cum somnus finit - Razgriz surget iterum

11
Posted Thursday, November 10th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
2308 ARP
808/2147482148, 2147481340 ARP to go
808/2147482148, 2147481340 ARP to go
ApocalypseWarrior said: I bought the game, and it's awesome. I love the kill confirmed mode, but unfortunately the multiplayer it's laggy for me, soo that sucks.
it's because there is not many people in country playing it? always check the ping bar. the game tries and searches games that are up to 150 ping.

12
Posted Thursday, November 10th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 3
473 ARP
223/250, 27 ARP to go
223/250, 27 ARP to go
dodolidot said: Hail CS!
CoD and BF never really got me
counterstrike didn't interest me as well. cod changed my life many years ago. still everyone have their own story.

13
Posted Thursday, November 10th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 3
473 ARP
223/250, 27 ARP to go
223/250, 27 ARP to go
BF3 is better. I haven't played COD and don't plan on it either. All it is is a re-skinned version of Modern Warfare 2 which was a horrible game.

Anything worth having is worth working hard for.

14
Posted Thursday, November 10th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
6397 ARP
4897/2147482148, 2147477251 ARP to go
4897/2147482148, 2147477251 ARP to go
BF is the COD for PC but now, BF is just plain better!

Press any key to continue...

15
Posted Thursday, November 10th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
3173 ARP
1673/2147482148, 2147480475 ARP to go
1673/2147482148, 2147480475 ARP to go
s8man888 said:
Eirreann said: is that the guy from Avatar and Clash of the Titans???
Yes that is Sam Worthington.


Sweeeeet! I wonder why he agreed to do this promotional... it's a pretty deep decline from Avatar...

"A single dream is more powerful than a thousand realities." ~ J.R.R. Tolkien

16
Posted Thursday, November 10th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
4956 ARP
3456/2147482148, 2147478692 ARP to go
3456/2147482148, 2147478692 ARP to go
Never played any of the Battlefield series so i opted out until i can get a used copy for cheaper. i did pick up MW3 (i've played every COD prior) and so far i like it. it does feel like a lot of the same or as a friend of mine said "a really expensive map pack" but it's the COD we all know and love, they're obviously (still) doing something right!

DEATH COMES QUICK

17
Posted Thursday, November 10th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 1
42 ARP
41/99, 58 ARP to go
41/99, 58 ARP to go
I Have the BF3, it's amazing, but I can't wait for the MW3 to arrive. (y)

18
Posted Thursday, November 10th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 1
98 ARP
97/99, 2 ARP to go
97/99, 2 ARP to go
I have played most of the Battlefield series. They are incredibly fun and, just the same, so is CoD. Though, I will always prefer Battlefield. Not quite sure why, but it has more appeal to me.
xD

Those who do understand thinking, those who think do not understand doing.

19
Posted Friday, November 11th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 6
1123 ARP
123/500, 377 ARP to go
123/500, 377 ARP to go
ok we can all agree that every single game coming out now is awesome

http://wolfcgc.webs.com/ Check it out good cheap computers!

20
Posted Friday, November 11th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 6
1001 ARP
1/500, 499 ARP to go
1/500, 499 ARP to go
I must say though this ad is amazing!

http://wolfcgc.webs.com/ Check it out good cheap computers!

21
Posted Friday, November 11th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 6
1001 ARP
1/500, 499 ARP to go
1/500, 499 ARP to go
BF3 and CS FTW. i dont like CoD that much cause of the aim assist so noob friendly. i know some people have it off but every time i see kill cam its always on

Hoo-Rah!

22
Posted Friday, November 11th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 5
920 ARP
170/250, 80 ARP to go
170/250, 80 ARP to go
Eirreann said:
s8man888 said:
Eirreann said: is that the guy from Avatar and Clash of the Titans???
Yes that is Sam Worthington.


Sweeeeet! I wonder why he agreed to do this promotional... it's a pretty deep decline from Avatar...


He got paid money for it. Maybe he plays CoD. Kobe did a Black Ops commercial and he just won a title. Activision has the money to spend on marketing. I personally like the commercial.

Each game has their own personality and charm, as well as flaws and imbalances. I have both and I like both for different reasons.

23
Posted Friday, November 11th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
4867 ARP
3367/2147482148, 2147478781 ARP to go
3367/2147482148, 2147478781 ARP to go
Havent played either getting skyrim today when i get off work. Why i dunno still work 10 hrs tomorrow and 12 the following two so dunno when ill play lol

xXNoobtubedXx

24
Posted Friday, November 11th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 7
7618 ARP
6118/2147482148, 2147476030 ARP to go
6118/2147482148, 2147476030 ARP to go
Yeah BF3 is fun and all...but I probably shouldn't have gotten it, too much time playing not enough in school work...

"He who controls the present, controls the past. He who controls the past, controls the future.

25
Posted Friday, November 11th, 2011    Quote This Post
Level 5
818 ARP
68/250, 182 ARP to go
68/250, 182 ARP to go
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 

Add Your Comment

You are not logged in. To leave a message you must Login First.