Author of The Witcher books came down hard on the game and keeps saying mostly complete nonsense

  • 341

Hold on, because this amount of nonsense is not recommended to consume at once. Writer of The Witcher books Andrzej Sapkowski spoke with portal Waypoint and casually said that his book popularized the game and not the other way around and that video games as a media cannot even tell a good story.

He claims that the games serve to another purpose of telling a good story and they just cannot have a sophisticated language that elevates cultural players. When CDPR made him an offer to make a game of his books, says he accepted the offer for the money and because he is not an idiot, but accuses developers actively trying to hide where they got the idea for the game.

At this he adds that the games are destroying his market and that is being follow only by children who do not know that the books occurred first. He also says that the books made the game popular because they were first popularized by his English translations. All of this is his opinion, but we can confirm that this statement is factually not true, because the translations into English came out after the first game.

Therefore, there is no problem with the fact that his book on the cover uses images from the game because it says that publishers are aware that some people only played games, but still claims that according to his assessment more people first read the book, and then got interested in games. It appears to us as if someone is injured that in the meantime has refused portion of the games sales that have crossed everyone's expectations.


 

Tagged with: Books, Sales of games and hardware, Witcher

Replies • 43

Wait witcher has books? might have to read those. Also the games are pretty good and Witcher 3 was one of the best games of that year. Maybe the author had some special connection with the series he made and wanted them portrayed in another way? 


As a followup from this thread https://na.alienwarearena.com/ucf/show/1511918/boards/gaming-news/News/it-was-stupid-the-witcher-book-writer-on-turning-down-a-share-of-cd-projekt-s-profits-1

How the hell kids are destroying his market? Isn't it better that your market is getting populated by possible kids that makes them interested in reading your books?

He is pretty sure about how his books made the game popular and not the game itself, but how does he have any credibility with that statement when he openly admitted that he is ignorant about the video game industry and how it works.

If i'm correct, witcher is Poland's most successful piece of entertainment since like forever. For one, the prime minister (former now i think) of poland gave Obama a copy of witcher 2 as it was one of their great things that came out of the country, and another is that a state postal services in there made a stamp with geralt's face on it. So the country seems to take pride in it.

Why not just embrace the amount of fame it got worldwide and especially in your country. It will make a lot of people open in reading the original source, people that otherwise wouldn't even hear about it if it weren't for the games.

Fact is, games are starting to offer great storytelling and some people just aren't aware of their huge potential.


All your base are belong to us.
OverFlowKyuubi said:

Wait witcher has books? might have to read those.

Books were written years before game was created. There are also movie (tragic) and tv series (average) with Witcher.


Planetary
OverFlowKyuubi said:

Wait witcher has books? might have to read those. Also the games are pretty good and Witcher 3 was one of the best games of that year. Maybe the author had some special connection with the series he made and wanted them portrayed in another way? 

It's based on books, and they are really good if you're into fantasy. Even though Sapkowski sounds a bit like a resentful idiot here, he's a good writer. 


When you create something and it turns to different thing, sometime you like sometime you hate. We cannot judge his feelings but words can be not decent.


Lunar

Wait a second...books still exist? I thought those were just a myth


Pan Andrzej is simply sad a bit about a price he've required for using his book subject. He did't believe that game will gain a millions. 
When you got a medium fixed price instead of a percent from great income, it's easy to be angry :)


I can add, I have seen movie serials about Witcher and it was more than 10 years ago, I guess serials was not better than books, but watching easier than read book.

SpaceInvader said:
OverFlowKyuubi said:

Wait witcher has books? might have to read those.

Books were written years before game was created. There are also movie (tragic) and tv series (average) with Witcher.

Ah they are that bad :( Might give the series a go, should watch the trailer. Are they just called Witcher or?


The cake is a lie

Once again it's all about $$$. Very sad situation.